It’s darkly humorous rather than an outright comedy, and its weirdness is a huge part of its charm.
Basket Case is one of those movies that seems like it shouldn’t work. Somehow, against all odds, it does.
Written and directed by Frank Henenlotter, the 1982 cult horror film stars Kevin Van Hentenryck as Duane Bradley, Terry Susan Smith as Sharon, Beverly Bonner as Casey, and Robert Vogel as the hotel manager. The story follows Duane and his formerly conjoined twin, Belial, on a bizarre and bloody mission of revenge.
Duane was born relatively normal, while Belial was essentially a malformed creature attached to his brother’s side. When the boys were twelve, they were surgically separated at the insistence of their father, who viewed Belial as a monster and wanted nothing to do with him. Belial was discarded, but Duane rescued his brother. Six years later, the two arrive in New York City, with Belial being carried around in a wicker basket, as they track down the doctors responsible for separating them.
The movie was reportedly made for around $35,000, and it’s a real testament to what can be accomplished with a tiny budget and a lot of conviction. The acting and special effects aren’t particularly polished, but they’re good enough to pull you into the story. More importantly, Henenlotter commits completely to the premise.
That commitment is what makes Basket Case work.
The film presents New York City as an incredibly grimy, sleazy, and dangerous place. In fact, the collection of bizarre characters Duane encounters makes the idea of walking around with a deformed creature in a wicker basket seem almost normal. The movie is filled with outrageous situations, but Henenlotter plays everything completely straight. That approach makes the craziness even funnier and, strangely enough, more believable.
Even though Belial obviously looks like a rubber puppet in many scenes — and the stop-motion sequences make him look more like a clay creature — the movie manages to convince you that he’s real within the world it creates. Before long, you actually find yourself feeling sympathy for Duane and Belial and becoming invested in their twisted quest for justice.
That’s probably the biggest surprise of Basket Case. Beneath all the sleaze, gore, and bizarre creature effects, there’s an oddly effective story about two brothers who have been rejected by the people who were supposed to care for them.
The movie eventually spawned two sequels, although I haven’t seen either of them. I’m not sure that I ever will. Basket Case feels like one of those rare lightning-in-a-bottle movies that would be nearly impossible to replicate. It’s a movie that shouldn’t work, but somehow manages to work extremely well.
It’s darkly humorous rather than an outright comedy, and its weirdness is a huge part of its charm. This definitely isn’t a movie I’d recommend to somebody looking for a conventional horror film. But if you’re interested in exploitation cinema, grindhouse movies, or cult horror, Basket Case is a pretty great place to start.
You couldn’t do much better — or much weirder — than this.
3.5 out of 5.0 stars


