Thanksgiving (2023)A Plymouth policeman dons one of the John Carver masks handed out to celebrate Thanksgiving.

This is a movie that’s a lot of fun while you’re watching it, but the second you stop and think about it, the whole thing starts to fall apart.

For those who don’t know, Thanksgiving has a pretty interesting origin story. It started as one of the fake trailers that appeared in the 2007 Grindhouse double feature from Quentin Tarantino and Robert Rodriguez. Over the years, several of those fake trailers have become actual movies, including Machete and Hobo with a Shotgun. Eventually, director Eli Roth and writer Jeff Rendell decided to turn their fake trailer into a full-length feature film.

The movie takes place in Plymouth, Massachusetts and opens with a Black Friday sale at a store called RightMart. Things quickly spiral out of control when the owner’s daughter sneaks her friends into the store through a side entrance, triggering a massive stampede. Several people are killed or seriously injured in what becomes known as the “Black Friday Massacre.”

One year later, the people connected to that tragedy begin receiving mysterious Instagram tags from someone calling themselves John Carver, the name as the founder of Plymouth. The posts feature a Thanksgiving dinner table with place settings labeled with the names of those involved in the massacre. As Thanksgiving approaches, those names begin getting crossed off in the most permanent way possible as a killer dressed as a Pilgrim starts picking them off one by one.

I’ll give Thanksgiving credit where it’s due. Eli Roth has built a reputation on movies like Hostel, and he clearly loves practical gore effects. If you’re a fan of old-school slasher makeup effects and gruesome kills, this movie delivers. In an era where so much horror relies on CGI, it was refreshing to see good old practical effects used so effectively.

The problem is that the movie never quite figures out what it wants to be. The original trailer was a loving parody of over-the-top 1980s slashers. It was ridiculous, funny, and completely self-aware. While some of that dark humor survives in the feature film, a lot of the parody atmosphere gets lost along the way.

The characters often feel like they’re acting in an ’80s slasher movie rather than behaving like actual modern teenagers, and while that may be intentional, it doesn’t always work. The humor is uneven, and several moments lifted directly from the trailer don’t have nearly the same impact when expanded into a full-length narrative.

This is a movie that’s a lot of fun while you’re watching it, but the second you stop and think about it, the whole thing starts to fall apart. Granted, plausibility has never exactly been a requirement for slasher films, but there’s something about Thanksgiving that keeps it from fully landing. Maybe it’s because the movie can’t quite decide whether it’s a parody, a tribute, or a straight slasher. Maybe I’m missing the point entirely. Either way, I’m not sure it matters.

What I can say is that I enjoyed myself. The kills are creative, the practical effects are excellent, and there’s undeniable entertainment value in watching a murderous Pilgrim stalk people around Plymouth. Eli Roth puts together some memorable set pieces, and horror fans will definitely find things to appreciate here.

Still, I couldn’t shake the feeling that the movie was missing something. The humor that made the original trailer so memorable never fully translates to the feature film, and stretching a concept that worked perfectly in a three-minute fake trailer into a nearly two-hour movie may not have been the best idea without fully embracing what made the trailer special in the first place.

In the end, Thanksgiving is entertaining, but it’s not a modern slasher classic. Instead, it serves as a reminder of just how great the slasher boom of the 1980s really was.

3.0 out of 5.0 stars

By Sean

Sean started The Projectionist on GeoCities in 1997. After reviewing movies there for 9 years, he created MediaAssault, a movie, music, and video game review site. Created in 2018, MovieAssault contains the movie reviews from those previous sites and continues their legacy to this day. Wanting to concentrate on movies again, MovieAssault was born. The site incorporates reviews from The Projectionist, MediaAssault, and newly-written reviews. It has since spawned a YouTube channel, @MovieAssault, and a bi-weekly podcast, Talking Movies with Sean, Kenny & Jim.