I can understand why people who love romantic movies hold this one in such high regard…but I can’t really say that I enjoyed it.
It’s time for the final entry in my Seventies in September series: The Way We Were from 1973, starring Barbra Streisand and Robert Redford. The film was directed by Sydney Pollack and written by Arthur Laurents, with uncredited script work from some names you may have heard of, including Francis Ford Coppola, Paddy Chayefsky, Dalton Trumbo, and Herb Gardner. Along with Streisand and Redford, the film stars Bradford Dillman as J.J. and Lois Chiles as Carol Anne.
I remember when this movie came out. I was probably about five years old, and you could not escape the soundtrack. The title song, performed by Barbra Streisand, was absolutely everywhere. I believe my mom had the album or at least the single because I remember hearing that song constantly at home. And because of that song and the promotional material for the movie, I wrote The Way We Were off as just a sappy love story. After finally watching it, I discovered that it’s really not that simple.
The story begins in the late 1930s and centers on Katie Morosky, played by Streisand, a politically active Jewish woman who is deeply committed to her causes. She becomes interested in Hubbell Gardner, played by Robert Redford, a handsome, athletic, and very different type of person.
While they’re in college, Katie initially sees Hubble as little more than a good-looking guy without much substance. But she becomes intrigued when something he has written that gives her a glimpse of what is going on beneath the surface. Hubbell is also interested in Katie, although he already has a girlfriend, so she keeps him at arm’s length.
Eventually, the two go their separate ways, but they meet again toward the end of World War II. Hubbell is drunk at a party, and Katie takes him home. It becomes clear that she has thought about him since they last saw each other, and once Hubbell sobers up, the two begin a romantic relationship.Unfortunately, it doesn’t take long before that relationship starts to fall apart.
The biggest problem is that Katie and Hubbell are simply very different people. Katie is completely committed to her political beliefs and her desire to make the world a better place. She feels that if she isn’t actively working toward something, she’s wasting her time. Hubbell, on the other hand, is much more laid-back. He enjoys spending time with his friends and generally doesn’t get involved in things unless they directly affect him. Neither of them is necessarily a bad person, but their core beliefs are so different that it’s difficult to see how their relationship could really work.
I actually really liked the chemistry between Streisand and Redford. Some of my favorite scenes were the ones where they were just talking and joking around with each other. Their humor felt natural, and their back-and-forth was genuinely entertaining. The problem is that I didn’t really buy them as a couple.
To me, they seemed much more believable as two people who appreciated each other and enjoyed being around each other than as a couple who were destined to be together. I enjoyed watching them interact, but when the movie wanted me to believe that they were madly in love, I just didn’t feel it. The intentional back-and-forth of their relationship also becomes a little repetitive. The movie keeps returning to the question of whether these two people can overcome their differences, and eventually that started to wear on me.
Maybe that’s the point. Maybe the movie is about how love can make people pursue relationships that, logically, they probably shouldn’t pursue. Sometimes two people can have an undeniable attraction to each other while still being completely wrong for one another. If that’s what the movie is trying to say, I can appreciate it. It just didn’t really work for me.
I have to admit that romance isn’t really my forte, especially tragic romances, so I’m probably not the target audience for The Way We Were. I can understand why people who love romantic movies hold this one in such high regard, and I certainly don’t think it’s the sappy love story that I originally assumed it was going to be. But I can’t really say that I enjoyed it.
3.0 out of 5.0 stars


