The Deadly Mantis (1957)The once-frozen giant preying mantis attacks!

The biggest problem with The Deadly Mantis is that it’s boring.

It’s October 1, 2026, which means the annual Halloween Fifteen is back! I’m kicking things off this year with 1957’s The Deadly Mantis, directed by Nathan Juran and written by Martin Berkeley from a story by producer William Alland. The film stars Craig Stevens as Colonel Joe Parkman, William Hopper as Dr. Ned Jackson, Alix Talton as Marge Blaine, and Donald Randolph as Major General Mark Ford.

If you know anything about me, you know that I love giant monster movies. Ever since I was a kid watching Superhost on Saturday mornings, I’ve been fascinated by those classic atomic-age monster movies where some ordinary creature gets exposed to radiation, grows to gigantic proportions, and proceeds to destroy buildings and attack military hardware. Movies like The Beast from 20,000 Fathoms, Godzilla, and Them! are exactly the kind of stuff I grew up loving.

The Deadly Mantis certainly features a giant creature, but this time radiation isn’t responsible. Instead, the giant mantis has apparently been frozen in the Arctic for thousands of years and is released after a volcanic eruption in the South Atlantic. How does an eruption in the South Atlantic thaw something out in the Arctic? The movie’s explanation is basically that every reaction has an equal and opposite reaction. You just have to love the logic of these movies.

Once it’s released, the giant mantis begins attacking military installations along the distant early warning radar line stretching across Canada. This system was designed to detect a potential Soviet nuclear attack, but apparently the world’s most sophisticated radar system can’t detect a gigantic flying insect because it simply flies underneath the radar.

People begin disappearing from the military installations, leaving behind destruction but no bodies. The military is completely stumped until a C-47 cargo plane is attacked. The crew disappears, but investigators discover a five-foot-long claw in the wreckage. After consulting a group of scientists, including Dr. Ned Jackson from the Department of Natural History, they determine that the claw belongs to a gigantic insect.

Dr. Jackson and his assistant Marge head to the Arctic to investigate. Of course, putting an attractive woman into an otherwise all-male military installation causes the testosterone level at the base to go through the roof. Colonel Joe Parkman becomes particularly interested in Marge and seems to take every opportunity he can to try to kiss her.

Parkman is also apparently the most important military officer in North America. He flies the fighter jet that attacks the mantis, investigates the destruction it causes, and ultimately plays a major role in defeating it. The entire military is mobilized to fight this creature, yet somehow Colonel Parkman is involved in virtually everything that happens.

One of the things I normally enjoy most about giant monster movies is the special effects. Most 1950s atomic-age creature features didn’t exactly have huge effects budgets, so the results can be pretty hit-or-miss. Surprisingly, the effects in The Deadly Mantis are actually pretty good when the creature is on the ground. The mantis looks convincing enough for a low-budget 1950s monster movie, and the effects didn’t bother me nearly as much as I expected. Unfortunately, things fall apart once the mantis takes flight. The flying sequences are much less impressive and are easily the weakest part of the effects work. Still, the special effects are probably the strongest thing the movie has going for it.

Unfortunately, I can’t say the same for the writing, acting, or pacing. The biggest problem with The Deadly Mantis is that it’s boring. That’s probably the worst thing a movie like this can be. There’s virtually no suspense. There’s no real sense of danger, and there’s never a point where you genuinely believe that the monster is going to kill anyone important. Even though this is supposed to be a giant monster attacking military installations, the movie never generates much excitement.

A lot of the action is also made up of stock footage. You’ll see one military plane taking off, a completely different plane during the action sequence, and yet another plane landing. That’s always been one of my pet peeves with stock footage. If you’re going to use footage of a plane taking off, fighting, and landing, the least you can do is make sure it looks like the same plane. There’s even a sequence involving the mantis attacking an Inuit village that was essentially lifted from the 1933 film S.O.S. Iceberg, minus the footage of the mantis itself.

I don’t expect a whole lot from my atomic-age monster movies. I love them for what they are, and I’m willing to overlook plenty of ridiculous science, questionable acting, and bargain-basement effects. But I expect them to be entertaining. Unfortunately, The Deadly Mantis doesn’t deliver.

1.5 out of 5.0 stars

By Sean

Sean started The Projectionist on GeoCities in 1997. After reviewing movies there for 9 years, he created MediaAssault, a movie, music, and video game review site. Created in 2018, MovieAssault contains the movie reviews from those previous sites and continues their legacy to this day. Wanting to concentrate on movies again, MovieAssault was born. The site incorporates reviews from The Projectionist, MediaAssault, and newly-written reviews. It has since spawned a YouTube channel, @MovieAssault, and a bi-weekly podcast, Talking Movies with Sean, Kenny & Jim.