Witchfinder General (1968)Matthew Hopkins (Vincent Price) leers at one of his victims.

It’s dark, disturbing and extremely moody, with an excellent performance from Vincent Price at its center.

For entry #2 in the 2026 version of The Halloween Fifteen, I’m taking a look at 1968’s Witchfinder General.

Directed by Michael Reeves and written by Tom Baker and Reeves, based on the novel by Ronald Bassett, the film stars Vincent Price as Matthew Hopkins, Ian Ogilvy as Richard Marshall, Hilary Dwyer as Sarah, and Robert Russell as John Stearne. It was released in the United States under the title The Conqueror Worm, a title chosen to connect it to the Edgar Allan Poe movies released by American International Pictures. Despite the title, the movie has nothing to do with Poe’s poem “The Conqueror Worm.”

Horror is an interesting genre because it can encompass so many different types of movies. The one thing they generally have in common is that they’re supposed to be scary, but what people consider scary can be very different. Some people are frightened by jump scares, while others find something scary simply because it leaves them with an unsettling thought.

Witchfinder General falls into that second category. It isn’t necessarily scary in the traditional sense, but it’s disturbing because it demonstrates just how cruel human beings can be when they believe they’re acting with some sort of moral or religious justification. It’s a great example of folk horror.

The story takes place during the English Civil War and follows Matthew Hopkins, who claims to have been appointed by Parliament to investigate accusations of witchcraft. Hopkins and his assistant, John Stearne, travel from village to village investigating supposed witches. In reality, the accusations are often based on grudges, and Hopkins uses torture and fear to force people into confessing.

The methods used against these accused witches are absolutely brutal. People are beaten, branded, stabbed with spikes in an attempt to find the supposed “Devil’s mark,” and subjected to drowning tests. The logic behind these tests is completely twisted. If you’re thrown into the water and drown, you were innocent. If you manage to swim, that supposedly proves you’re a witch, so you’re killed anyway. In other words, once you’re accused, you’re basically already condemned.

Hopkins eventually arrives in the village of Brandeston to investigate accusations against a priest, John Lowes. Lowes’ niece, Sarah, is engaged to a soldier named Richard Marshall. Sarah attempts to bargain for her uncle’s life by offering herself to Hopkins, but Hopkins takes advantage of her and Lowes is ultimately killed anyway. When Marshall returns and discovers what Hopkins has done, he vows to get revenge.

Vincent Price is fantastic in this movie. His performance as Matthew Hopkins is very different from the more theatrical roles he’s often associated with. Instead of the flamboyant, sinister character we might expect from Price, he’s incredibly restrained. Hopkins is calm, composed and almost emotionless, which makes him even more disturbing.

He’s essentially a man who has discovered that his supposed authority gives him tremendous power over other people. He’s motivated by greed, collecting rewards from the villages for eliminating their supposed witchcraft problems. The more power and money he gets, the more corrupt he becomes.

That’s what makes Witchfinder General so frightening. The movie isn’t trying to scare you with ghosts, monsters or jump scares. It’s showing you what ordinary human beings are capable of doing to each other when they’re given unchecked power or convinced that they’re acting in the name of morality.

The movie isn’t perfect, though. I found the pacing to be somewhat uneven. As beautiful as the cinematography is, there are quite a few scenes of men riding horseback through the countryside that don’t add much suspense or energy to the story. Those sequences occasionally slow the movie down.

Fortunately, the film’s brutal depiction of cruelty more than makes up for those slower stretches, and Price’s performance is compelling enough to keep the movie moving.

If you’re looking for a period horror film that goes in a very different direction from the usual haunted house or supernatural story, Witchfinder General is definitely worth checking out. It’s dark, disturbing and extremely moody, with an excellent performance from Vincent Price at its center.

It may not be scary in the traditional sense, but the idea behind the movie is arguably more frightening than any supernatural creature could be. The fact that people can be so cruel to one another while convincing themselves that they’re doing the right thing is what makes this movie stick with you.

3.5 out of 5.0 stars

By Sean

Sean started The Projectionist on GeoCities in 1997. After reviewing movies there for 9 years, he created MediaAssault, a movie, music, and video game review site. Created in 2018, MovieAssault contains the movie reviews from those previous sites and continues their legacy to this day. Wanting to concentrate on movies again, MovieAssault was born. The site incorporates reviews from The Projectionist, MediaAssault, and newly-written reviews. It has since spawned a YouTube channel, @MovieAssault, and a bi-weekly podcast, Talking Movies with Sean, Kenny & Jim.